This site is run by widowed people, for widowed people

Widowed Village connects peers with each other for friendship and sharing. The moderators, administrators, and others involved in running this site are not professionals.

Please don't interpret anything you read here as medical, legal, or otherwise expert advice. Don't disregard any expert's advice or take any action as a result of what you read here.

We're friends, not doctors, financial or legal professionals, and we're not "grief experts." But we are here, and we've been "there."

Ashes, Judgement and Mythical Closure

I glanced at the book Small Victories by Anne Lamont today and as I was getting ready to place it on a cart to be re-shelved a small voice inside said, ‘read this.’ I’m trying hard to listen to that voice and so I curiously opened it directly to a page where author Anne Lamont is recalling spreading her friend’s ashes.


This caught my attention fast. I still have most of John’s ashes except a few cups I released into Lake Michigan last year. I often think of releasing what is left of them and then back down from the idea – not ready - too permanent an action for me, as if his death isn’t permanent. Still, even though I know he never thought that three plus years after his death I would still have his ashes, I do. There is a level of pain that accompanies their disappearance completely that I can’t quite explain and I suppose because these years have been so incredibly painful I have avoided adding to it.


In the book Lamont says that ashes are both “so heavy and so light. That they are impossible to let go of entirely. They stick to things, to your fingers, your sweater.” This was my experience as well. I waded into Lake Michigan and crouched down low near the water so John’s ashes wouldn’t be blown about so much. I even waited until the tide was in and just getting ready to recede before I poured them in but as often is Nature had other plans, small wave after wave came in then and they swirled around my feet, my pant legs and legs. John’s ashes were as difficult to release physically as they were emotionally, even after they were submerged and merged with the great lakes’ water they were still in my heart, still heavy. I sometimes find that even though I know it was good to have relinquished them back to the One, which is as it should be, that I wish I hadn’t.


Later, in the book Lamont talks about how the ashes stuck to her fingers and how she licked them off, “ I licked my friend's ashes off my hand, to taste them, to taste her, to taste what was left after all that was clean and alive had ben consumed, burned away.  They tasted metallic.”


I’ve actually read on blogs that others have done this as well and their admissions often bring horrified comments or judgment. I have not tasted John’s ashes but often wondered how different could it be really from tasting him when he was alive? I don’t mean that in an inappropriate or sexual way but in a daily living together sort of way. The salty taste of his kiss after a workout, the taste of his skin when I would taste something off of his finger he had cooked or the vague taste of his mouth when I would occasionally need to borrow his toothbrush. These tastes are as individual and intimate as your mate's smell and after he died I found I missed them too. So I would just as often be likely to be found sniffing his shirts as I would be holding his toothbrush in my mouth, to taste him, to be as close to what was left of his DNA as I could. Grief is not logical after all.


Ashes don’t go quietly leaving no trace behind. Releasing them for me has given no more of that mythical closure I've read about than any other ritual I’ve engaged in. What they do according to Lamont is “they cling, they haunt” and even though I’m not actually haunted by John’s ashes, I am haunted by his death.

His ashes have become a normal part of the tapestry of things that make up my home.  Those who know me well know the beautiful pottery piece that contains them and those that know me very well will sometime ask to visit them alone, to visit John.  

I have lots of back and forth feelings of guilt for having them still and then I have similar feelings over having released them back into the cycle, which I know he would have preferred, which I know I am often judged about by grief outsiders, and I’m working on it, it just appears I’m working at it very slowly. I'm working on it at widow's speed.

Views: 149


You need to be a member of Widowed Village to add comments!

Join Widowed Village

Comment by flannery on December 10, 2015 at 7:58am

Thank you Laurajay and Callie2. It helps os much to have those who know understand. I do believe John has long since returned to God, I just feel a little guilty about interrupting the cycle of life, allowing him to reenter and that energy to feed something lovely- a tree, the waters, flowers. But I'm not read yet and I'm just going to have to be where I am. As far as the books are concerned oh law do I understand that. I have lists and piles to read and thank goodness for them. Nothing brings quite as much bliss as a good book. Hugs, Flan

Comment by laurajay on December 8, 2015 at 9:49pm know I  love your writing- every blog is written so well.  My beliefs are in tune with Callie 2's comment.   Your husband and  others who have died have already   returned to their maker or as you said the One when their spirit left their body as they died.    We are only given these bodies so our spirit can move about while we experience life on is no longer of use when we are dead.   I don't think it matters at all what you do with what has been left behind-ashes.  Just live each day as your heart dictates and see what happens in the future.   Our bodies come from nothing and return to nothing-   ashes to is the spirit that lives on through eternity  unless you believe otherwise. You owe no one  explanations not even yourself.  Do what feels comfortable and timely.   It is not his ashes that  still bind the two of you together but rather the love you pledged to share forever.  Long after the dust has blown away or even if it stays confined to a sealed container,  it is the love you shared that will endlessly endure.  I do not wish to dismiss your feelings or  beliefs just expressing my viewpoint  which I perceive to be different than yours.  Your post reminds me I have such a large stack of books to much still to learn.  Sending you my love and  holy  peace  in your decision making.   Blessings.     lj

Comment by Callie2 on December 8, 2015 at 1:49pm
Not knowing your husband's wishes, I can only guess that he wouldn't mind that you hold on to them for as long as you need to. There is no harm, far as I can think. I know people who have held on to them for an extended period of time and later, had them buried. Please don't feel guilty about delaying this, you are doing nothing wrong or immoral. Your reasoning for not wanting to do this or to do this now, seem reasonable to me. In my opinion, you don't have to be concerned about returning him to the One--he has already left here to do that. Maybe you have religious reasons to feel this way and I do respect that, but I have always felt that when we die, we are no longer inside that body. If you feel at some point you do need to release the ashes somewhere--would you consider asking a family member or close friend to do it for you? Just another alternative. For now, I wouldn't worry about what anyone else thinks, in fact, this is a personal issue one that is totally your decision and should be on your timeline, not on someone else's.

© 2019   Created by Soaring Spirits.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service